New DVD Player vs. Vintage CD Player: What to choose for your audio system

Not long ago, I read an article that asked why anyone would buy a CD player when a modern DVD player could perform the job of playing music equally as well.

I also recall that soon after I began buying and selling audio gear, I had a similar conversation with a friend in which we discussed the future of the CD player, and especially the used and/or vintage CD players. This particular conversation was sparked by the fact that I would often buy complete systems, from which I would end up with all sorts of CD players that I thought no-one would want. Indeed, a year ago I found it difficult to even give these players away; these older CD players were not even worth the hassle of selling.

But a year is a long time in  audio, and good condition, functioning, classic CD players are becoming sought-after commodities.

So what has changed?

For a start, the 30th anniversary of the compact disc and the CD player is nearly upon us, and this means that one, nearly two, generations have always lived in a world where CDs have always been around. This timeframe is also long enough for a certain nostalgia to take hold, and for a number of people to start looking back fondly on these earlier players. More and more I am seeing both serious collectors and “assemeblers” chasing after older CD players. What do I mean by “assemblers”? These are the people that realise the interesting design styles and characteristics of early CD players which makes them stand out in comparison to the blandness of modern players, and these assemblers are adding vintage CD players into the classic audio systems in their super-cool homes as a talking point. (Interestingly, I’ve seen an surge of interest in cassette decks too for this same reason).

I too have come to  appreciate more and more the aesthetics of these early players. Even the 15-20 year-old players have a beauty, a solidity that has almost disappeared in recent CD and DVD players.

Most sought after are from the follwing brands: Philips, Pioneer Stable Platter, Sony ES, Marantz, Onkyo Integra, Technics AA & MASH.

Benefits of vintage CD players:

1) Fast loading of discs.

2) Detailed display.

3) Multiple play options available on the front of the deck.

4) Quiet operation!!!.

5) Fucking cool looking (Check out the Onkyo below. More buttons than you will ever push).

5) Some great, classic DACs to be found in 20+ year old decks.

6) Can often be found cheaply.

Against vintage CD players:

1) Laser strength and longevity are a lottery.

2) Parts (mainly lasers) are impossible to find for many of the better models.

3) Expensive and sometimes difficult to  fix.

4) No remote control (or it’s gone missing).

5) Often don’t play burned discs.

For DVD Players:

1) Cheap!

2) Generally good 192/24 DACs — good enough that it is often impossible to differentiate between low and high end gear (confirmed by blind tests).

3) Lasers can read anything thrown at them.

4) They have optical and co-axial outs, so can be used as adequate transports.

Against DVD players (when used for audio).

1) Slow.

2) Noisy.

3) No display.

4) Shit styling.

5) Lightweight (The top of the line Sony DVD/SACD player below only weighs a couple of kilograms).

Conclusion: if you are just a casual listener that doesn’t really care about sound quality or style, go for the DVD player. Otherwise, jump into the murky world of vintage CD players and hope you get lucky. As for myself, I think the solution may lie somewhere in between, namely buying a high-end older DVD player. There is some amazing quality pieces out there that can be had cheaply as rich people are getting rid of them in order to upgrade to HDMI and Blu-Ray. Look out for big Pioneers, Yamahas, Oppos and Denons as these all used quality DACs.

2 Comments on “New DVD Player vs. Vintage CD Player: What to choose for your audio system”

  1. Webpage says:

    obviously as if your web site but the truth is should examine the spelling in some of your posts. A few of them will be rife along with punctuational challenges and I believe it is pretty worrisome to tell the fact having said that I’m going to surely come all over again once again.

  2. Philip McAlpine says:

    Wondering if my CD player can be classed as ‘vintage’ – it a 24 year old Sony CDP-555ESD, mint condition like it just came out of the box and (everything crossed) the laser goes on and on and on…. Built like a battleship, 14Kg of superb Sony engineering – still sounds as musical as many of the modern CD players I’ve listened to. Had it modified by Audiocom to upgrade the masterclock which smoothed it out just a touch. I’ll be keeping it as a paperweight when the laser finally goes !.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s